303.666.4133

For most of history, survival gave humanity a clear purpose. If machines eventually provide the intelligence, labor, creativity, and coordination required to sustain civilization, humanity will confront a question that technology alone cannot answer: Why do we matter?

Here’s a question nobody wants to ask out loud at a tech conference: If machines can do everything better than we can, what exactly are we for?

It sounds like a late-night dorm-room question. It isn’t. I believe it will become the defining political, spiritual, and economic question of this century. Not because the answer is unknowable, but because we’ve never had to answer it before.

For 300,000 years, the answer was handed to us. We were for surviving. We hunted, planted, built, defended, and raised children so the tribe could continue. Purpose wasn’t a philosophy. It was a necessity. Nobody wondered why they mattered while running from a predator.

That era is ending. And we are wildly unprepared for what comes next.

Keynes Saw This Coming in 1930

Nearly a century ago, economist John Maynard Keynes wrote a short essay called Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren. He predicted that technology would eventually solve humanity’s oldest problem, the struggle to survive. Then he made a startling observation. Humans, he argued, have been shaped by nature for exactly that struggle, so if it’s ever solved, “mankind will be deprived of its traditional purpose.”

Keynes believed our real challenge, the permanent one, would be how to use our freedom from pressing economic cares and how to fill the leisure that science and compound interest will have won for us. He worried it would be a fearful problem for the ordinary person.

Keynes was writing about our generation. His 100-year window closes in 2030. And the technology he couldn’t have imagined, artificial intelligence, is arriving right on schedule to test his theory.

The greatest family vacation may leave more than memories—a lasting legacy built by three generations, changing lives long after the travelers return home.

The Last Monopoly Is Breaking

Every previous wave of technology took something from us, but it always left us something to retreat to.

The Industrial Revolution replaced our muscles, so we moved to our minds. Computers replaced our arithmetic, so we moved to judgment, creativity, and strategy. Each time, humans found higher ground.

AI is different. It’s climbing the same hill we’ve been retreating up. It writes poetry. It composes music. It diagnoses disease, designs drugs, negotiates contracts, and generates art that wins competitions. Soon it will coordinate supply chains, run laboratories, and manage cities.

What’s left? Philosopher Nick Bostrom has explored this scenario in his book Deep Utopia. He imagines a world where AI goes right, where human labor becomes obsolete and we enter a condition of “post-instrumentality,” in which our efforts are not needed for any practical purpose. As he puts it, this is a challenge that is not technological but philosophical and spiritual. In such a solved world, what is the point of human existence? What gives meaning to life? What do we do all day?

That’s not a dystopia. That’s the best-case scenario. And it still raises a question that could tear societies apart.

Why This Question Is Dangerous

I call it the most dangerous question of the century for three reasons.

First, bad answers are easy to sell. When people feel useless, they become vulnerable to anyone who offers them a sense of significance. History shows that movements built on grievance and belonging thrive in times of displacement. Millions of people without purpose are fertile ground for extremists, cults, and demagogues who promise to make them matter again.

Second, someone else may answer it for us. If we don’t decide what humans are for, the decision will default to whoever controls the machines. Corporations may decide humans are for consuming. Governments may decide humans are for complying. Neither answer leaves much room for dignity.

Third, the wrong answer could devalue human life itself. If a person’s worth is measured by economic output, and machines out-produce every human, then the logic becomes chilling. We’ve spent centuries building the idea that every person has inherent value. That idea has never been tested against a world where most people aren’t economically needed.

The future of travel isn’t about visiting places. It’s about becoming part of them, building lasting relationships, and leaving communities stronger than you found them.

Five Answers Worth Considering

I don’t think there’s one correct answer. But here are five worth debating, and each points to a very different future.

1. Humans are for caring. Machines can simulate empathy, but they don’t truly care whether you live or die. Some thinkers argue that our role is to be the ones who are responsible, the stewards who decide what matters. A grandmother holding a newborn isn’t performing a task. She’s expressing love. No efficiency gain replaces that.

2. Humans are for choosing. AI can optimize anything, but it can’t decide what’s worth optimizing. Should we cure aging or explore Mars first? Should cities favor privacy or safety? These are value questions. Someone has to own them. In a world of infinite capability, deciding what we want may be the most important job left.

3. Humans are for experiencing. Maybe the point was never to produce. Maybe it was to feel the sun, taste a ripe peach, fall in love, and laugh until it hurts. A machine can describe a sunset. Only a conscious being can be moved by one. In this view, humans are the universe’s way of experiencing itself.

4. Humans are for striving. We climb mountains not because we need to reach the top, but because the climb transforms us. Chess didn’t die when computers beat world champions. More people play today than ever. Purpose may come from voluntary challenge, from games, crafts, sports, and quests we choose because they’re hard.

5. Humans are for becoming. Perhaps our purpose is growth itself: to keep learning, expanding, and evolving into something we can’t yet imagine. In this view, AI isn’t our replacement. It’s our launchpad.

The Questions We Should Be Asking Now

If I’m right that this question is coming, then we should start preparing now, not after the crisis arrives. A few places to begin:

  • Schools should teach purpose, not just skills. Students should graduate knowing how to find meaning when no employer hands it to them.
  • Religious and philosophical communities should expect a resurgence. People will be hungry for frameworks that explain why they matter.
  • Governments should measure national well-being, not just economic output. A country with record GDP and collapsing purpose isn’t succeeding.
  • Tech companies should be asked, every time they automate a role, what happens to the human who used to fill it.

Tomorrow’s greatest luxury may not be escaping responsibility, but embracing it—traveling the world to discover the extraordinary privilege of being needed.

Final Thoughts

We’ve spent decades asking, “What can machines do?” That was the wrong question. The right question is, “What should humans do when machines can do everything?”

Here’s my provocation: the greatest risk of AI isn’t that it will destroy us. It’s that it will succeed so completely that we forget why we were worth saving.

Survival gave us purpose for 300,000 years. Now we have to choose one. For the first time in history, the meaning of human life won’t be dictated by necessity. It will be a decision.

And whatever we decide will shape every century that follows.

Related Articles